DISCUSSION/OFF-TOPIC POST

[themodawakens]

Use this post for things that are neither prompts nor questions for the mod.

flat view

Comments

TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

It was mentioned upthread that some fics don't get enough love / feedback / kudos, etc. If you have a fic and would like some comments or feedback on please post a link to it here.

Constructive comments. Not everything has to be sunshine and gumdrops but there is no point in rudeness since people work really hard on these stories.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

Oh, I don't think so. Like painting a target on it.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

Possibly, but I don't know how else to give those fics attention.

I don't want anyone to feel like they're going to be trolled or something, but there is a lot of good stuff that just gets lost on AO3 or even here just by virtue of being posted at the wrong time, or a million other reasons that are no one's fault really.

If this is a bad idea I'm sorry, really don't want to make anyone uncomfortable.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

Stop with this pointless fear-mongering. You're giving the trolls what they want by giving up before the fight even starts.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

I speak from horrifying personal experience. I'd hope that it would be a better experience for others, given this meme is notably more civil, but it's not a thing I'd ever do again.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

uh huh.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

da

this attitude is not helping counter the ayrt's point.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

Okay, I'll play. This is a Sith!Rey/Jedi!Ben fic written for a round 1 prompt that didn't get much attention. Also OP had probably moved on since then, as they were silent on the matter. I would welcome some con-crit.

http://tfa-kink.dreamwidth.org/1082.html?thread=514362#cmt514362

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

I will provide a much more in depth comment later on as I'm currently at work but I thank you for posting and want to start by saying that this is incredibly well written.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

Not the above anon, but I loved it and thought there was nothing wrong with it at all. I hadn't read it until this post because I only read Finn/Poe, but I thought it was excellent.

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

Thanks for linking, I hadn't caught this and am now dying to read it. Will provide con crit soon!

Re: TFA Fic Feedback

[(Anonymous)]

I'm reading it and really enjoy it! I think one thing you could spend more time on is to describe the setting more since it isn't very clear just from the story what things look like, where characters are currently, those sorts of things. :)